Book Review Chums

Book Review Chums: How a Tiny Caste of Oxford Tories Took Over the UK”

I write this review with the redbrick Union visible from my window and the sound of applause within earshot, though sometimes it is music (or, at night, unearthly shrieking). That gated edifice and the privilege it represents form the focus of Simon Kuper’s book Chums, which argues that Oxford was the crucial formative experience for the Tory coterie who went on to push Brexit.

Chums: How a Tiny Caste of Oxford Tories Took Over the UK by Simon Kuper – review

Reading this book as a current student, one is struck by how easily it might all happen again – or still be happening, with someday prime ministers as hacks, squabbling away with their future Cabinet. Kuper highlights the Union as a training ground for Parliament, a place for students to practice good oratory before launching into political careers, often along the well-worn path from Oxford to Westminster.

Boris Johnson’s tactics in running for Union president, he observes, were uncannily similar to his efforts at gaining Downing Street, and Kuper’s portrait of Johnson is the most interesting. We are told how our government leader honed his “charm” in the Union chamber, learning that sheer personality could attract voters. Still, his first (failed) attempt at presidency involved his then-girlfriend inviting his opponent for tea, asking him not to go against “my Boris”. Kuper notes that not much policy was enacted once he had won and, with an awful sense of fatalism, points towards his mishandling of the pandemic as conforming to a pattern.

CHUMS (HARDBACK)

…the main picture this presents is one of startling entitlement and, more dangerously, narrow thinking.

Where this book does best is in the obsessive tracking of connections: the Etonian Boris Johnson was messing about at the Bullingdon club while the spectacled Michael Gove led tours around the Union. Both Gove and Jacob Rees-Mogg (“dressed like a Victorian vicar” even then) had been awarded the title of “Pushy Fresher” by Cherwell and were popular objects of satire. Meanwhile, Keir Starmer argued for the printers’ strike at the Labour Club against the more centrist David Miliband. The Labour Club also held debates but with rules that “killed high-wire speechifying”; no wonder, as Kuper sadly suggests, Starmer is such a dull speaker.

Chums: How a Tiny Caste of Oxford Tories Took Over the UK

The hyper-intense focus on the Union of course risks complacency. It’s satisfying to read anecdotes such as how Nick Robinson, then president of the OUCA, goes on to present the Today program several decades later, “wherein October 2021 he told a verbose Johnson, ‘Prime minister stop talking’” – like having puzzle pieces click into shape. Yet the main picture this presents is one of startling entitlement and, more dangerously, narrow thinking.

That the political network at the height of the establishment is so intimately linked is no surprise, but the extent to which this affects policy is urgently relevant. With the economy still suffering from the impact of the pandemic, knowing that the government is dominated by elites willing to risk people’s livelihoods for a hole-ridden dream they had as twenty-somethings posing theories in their JCR seems far from reassuring.

Chums by Simon Kuper review — Loathe Brexit? Blame the Oxford set

This feels more tragic given that they tread in the shadows of men (they were mostly men) who invested much of their lives in trying to secure prosperity. There is a fascinating chapter called “A Generation without Tragedy”, which posits that politics have become less serious since the deaths of those who had first-hand experience in the wars. I had not realized that so many past prime ministers had engaged in direct conflict; Kuper states that from 1940 to 1963, Britain was ruled by individuals who had volunteered to fight in the First World War. It is sobering to consider how the UK’s entry into the EEC was influenced by a desire to avoid such conflict as would lead to death and devastation – while Brexit began almost at a Union boy’s whim.

Somewhere out there (heaven forbid!) a hack is dreaming of Downing Street.

Still, I am not quite so cynical as Kuper, whose solution to the problem of Oxford alumni dominating the establishment is to “stop them [the university] teaching undergraduates” altogether. I clearly have a vested interest in disagreeing, but the suggestion does seem terribly facile. Better to improve the access work already in place, or expand them further, than take it all apart.

A book like this necessarily involves an element of complicity. When Kuper (columnist at the Financial Times) notes how “Oxbridge men used their establishment podiums to issue ritual laments about the powers of Oxbridge men” but “they struggled to feel this viscerally”, the reader cannot help feeling that the pronoun should be “we”. What does it mean to “feel this viscerally”? To contend, engage with, and negotiate privilege is something that every student at Oxford, regardless of background, must do – though we are forced to in different ways.

Chums: How a Tiny Caste of Oxford Tories Took Over the UK

There are parts of Oxford that do not speak to a narrative like the bleak one presented by Kuper. Last month, Oxford Against Conversion Therapy held a strong protest against the government’s refusal to ban conversion therapy. More recently, some colleges have voted to sign a pledge promoted by the Can’t Buy My Silence campaign to stop using non-disclosure agreements in cases of sexual violence, bullying, and other misconduct. There is a lot of dedicated effort especially by BAME reps to ensure an atmosphere of welcome and understanding. David Cameron who called the Brexit referendum in 2016 may be an alumnus of my college, Brasenose, but it is hardly a point of pride.

I believe that, while there might be a future Boris Johnson II walking in our midst, it’s more likely that there are cleverer and kinder people. At least, I hope so.

It’s not a romanticized, rose-tinted view. Sure, there might be fireworks, garden parties, or jazz music floating through the night, from the Union visible from my window. But there are also drunken yells and crashes. Somewhere out there (heaven forbid!) a hack is dreaming of Downing Street. But there are more who dream of better.

 

Featured image description: a view of Oxford against a cloudy sky

Featured image credits: Liv Cashman via Unsplash

Chums: How a Tiny Caste of Oxford Tories Took Over the UK 

https://www.theguardian.com › books › may › chums-h

01-May-2022 — A penetrating analysis of the connections that enabled an incestuous university network to dominate Westminster and give birth to Brexit is 

Chums – Profile Books

https://profilebooks.com › Works

28-Apr-2022 — Reviews for Chums · ‘A searing onslaught on the smirking Oxford insinuation that politics is all just a game. · ‘A gripping read … exquisite and 

Chums by Simon Kuper | Waterstones

https://www.waterstones.com › book › simon-kuper

Chums (Hardback) … Detailing the troubling amounts of political power wielded by a very small and privileged Oxford elite, Kuper’s excellently researched and 

People also search for

control bookatoms and ashescontrol: the dark history

waterstones non fictionhow to write book review

Chums: How a Tiny Caste of Oxford Tories Took Over the UK

https://www.goodreads.com › book › show

The author tries to win our sympathy by defining himself apart from the establishment subjects of the book, even though he’s an Oxford-educated FT columnist …

 Rating: 4 · ‎82 votes

Chums by Simon Kuper review — Loathe Brexit? Blame the 

https://www.thetimes.co.uk › article › chums-by-simon-ku

30-Apr-2022 — It is a fascinating book even if its thesis is perhaps half banal and half overextended. Basically, it is that most senior people in public 

People also search for

control bookatoms and ashescontrol: the dark history

waterstones non fictionhow to write book review

Chums: How a Tiny Caste of Oxford Tories Took Over the UK 

https://www.amazon.co.uk › Chums-Tiny-Caste-Oxford.

This book provides insights into what is wrong with our country and why we are in such desperate trouble at the moment with the generation of politicians who 

Chums: How a Tiny Caste of Oxford Tories Took Over the UK

https://www.amazon.com › product-reviews

Customer Reviews, including Product Star Ratings help customers to learn more about the product and decide whether it is the right product for them. To 

People also search for

control bookatoms and ashescontrol: the dark history

waterstones non fictionhow to write book review

Book Chums – Reviews of best selling books

https://www.bookchums.com

Books Inspire you more than anything in this world. A book can transform your personality in a way you will never know. We at BookChums research the best in 

People also search for

control bookatoms and ashescontrol: the dark history

waterstones non fictionhow to write book review

MIDDLE GRADE BOOK REVIEW: Chum by Adam Glendon 

https://www.pinterest.com › pin

Oct 22, 2014 – CHUM by Adam Glendon Sidwell Future House Publishing, 2014 ISBN13: 9780989125338 Middle Grade Adventure Grades 4-8 Source: eARC

CHUM by Mark Spitzer – Fiction Book Review – Publishers 

https://www.publishersweekly.com › 

CHUM. Mark Spitzer, Author . Zoland $21 (227p) ISBN 978-1-58195-031-1. Erstwhile porn star April Berger, shipwrecked on the Alaskan island of Lo, 

“Pigs at the trough” – Chums by Simon Kuper – Bookmunch

https://bookmunch.wordpress.com › 2022/05/13 › pigs

13-May-2022 — I can’t imagine for one second that reading Simon Kuper’s bookChums … the old despair we were talking about at the start of the review.

Chums | Simon Kuper | London Review Bookshop

https://www.londonreviewbookshop.co.uk › stock › chum…

28-Apr-2022 — Eleven of the fifteen postwar British prime ministers went to Oxford. In Chums, Simon Kuper traces how the rarefied and privileged atmosphere of 

Buy Chums… by Severne Harleigh at Low Price in India

https://www.flipkart.com › chums

Chums… (English, Paperback, Severne Harleigh). Be the first to Review this product … This is a reproduction of a book published before 1923.

All the Chums Books in Order | Toppsta

https://toppsta.com › Series

Four stray dogs all with a story to tell of their rescue and how they came to live at Munchy Flats Cottage with their … More. (0 reviews). ReviewBook 2.

Book Review: The Missing Chums by Franklin W. Dixon 

http://carstairsconsiders.blogspot.com › 2019/01 › book

20-Jan-2019 — I mean, who says “chum” any more when referring to their friends? Honestly, I think I only know this word thanks to this book. Of course, the 

The Missing Chums — “The Hardy Boys” Series – Plugged In

https://www.pluggedin.com › Books

Book Review. The Missing Chums by Franklin W. Dixon is a Focus on the Family book published in association with Tyndale House Publishers.

My review of ANTIDOTING CHUMS by Dr. Ojasvi Rikhi

https://grishmaninave.wordpress.com › 2018/01/05 › m

05-Jan-2018 — Cover – The book cover, a shade of black with sunrays and a picture of friends, is an awesome one. It is intriguing and makes one pick up the 

The Hardy Boys: The Missing Chums | 1 Review | D80147

https://www.daedalusbooks.com › 

How are the events related? One by one, Frank and Joe tackle the clues—hardly daring to think what might have happened to their missing friends—but they are …

 Rating: 5 · ‎1 review · ‎$2.48 · ‎Out of stock

Hail to the Chums – Claremont Review of Books

https://claremontreviewofbooks.com › hail-to-the-chums

Hail to the Chums … In his engaging new book, First Friends, Gary Ginsberg, a lawyer, corporate executive, and former government official, takes a look at 

The Once and Future King – Book Review

Ad·https://www.elizabeththinks.com/

Is The Once and Future King a must-read book for fans of the King Arthur story? Read the book review to find out

 

 

 

 

SOURCE URL

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.